Reserve Development Plan Report

1. Waipapa Papanui-Innes-Central Community Board Meeting (9th Nov 2026)
2. Shirley Community Reserve – Landscape Development Plan (CCC Staff Report)
3. Shirley Community Reserve Development Plan (Consultation Feedback)
4. Shirley Community Reserve Development Plan (Feedback Summary)
5. CCC Staff Report & ‘Final Landscape Plan’ (My Feedback)

– 5.1. Location Map & Safety Issues
– 5.2. Reserve Classification & History
– 5.3. Access, Visibility & Wayfinding
– 5.4. Activities & Funding
– 5.5. Reserve & Play Space Fencing


1. Waipapa Papanui-Innes-Central Community Board Meeting (9th Nov 2026)
https://christchurch.infocouncil.biz/Open/2026/11/PCBCC_20261109_AGN_11318_AT_WEB.htm
Item 7. Shirley Community Reserve – Landscape Development Plan


2. Shirley Community Reserve – Landscape Development Plan (CCC Staff Report)
3.5 Following consideration of submissions, several amendments were made to the draft plan, including changes to the skate area, play equipment and fencing arrangements. Requests for additional facilities and environmental initiatives that sit outside the project scope have been considered and responded to within this report.

Shirley Community Reserve
Landscape Development Plan
Draft | Version 1 | Prior to Consultation
(The wrong image is included in the CCC Staff Report.
4.9, Figure 1 shows the Final, Version 2 plan)
Shirley Community Reserve
Landscape Development Plan
Final | Version 2 | After the Consultation

3. Shirley Community Reserve Development Plan (Consultation Feedback)
While the ‘Early Feedback’ from our three local schools is included in the CCC Staff Report as ‘Attachments’.

The ‘Let’s Talk’ Consultation Submissions are not included as an ‘Attachment’ in the CCC Staff Report, to help inform elected members with their decision making.

‘Summary of Submissions Ngā Tāpaetanga’
7.24 Submissions were made by five recognised organisations and 20 individuals.
All submissions are available on our Kōrero mai webpage.
7.28 A wide range of comments were received that can be read in the submission document.

‘Let’s Talk’ Shirley Community Reserve Development Plan:
https://letstalk.ccc.govt.nz/SCRdevelopmentplan/agenda-available

‘Decision-making documents’:
Shirley Community Reserve landscape plan – submissions (Link):
https://www.10shirleyroad.org.nz/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/ShirleyCommunityReservedevelopmentplansubmissiondocumentpublic.pdf
My submission is included on Pages 37-45.

The following blog posts (updated/expanded submission) were also emailed to CCC Staff, please read these for more details:
– Reserve Development Plan Feedback
– Reserve Development Plan ‘Play’ Zone
– Reserve Development Plan ‘Move’ Zone
– MacFarlane Park South Play Space &

– Shirley Community Reserve Activation
9. Shirley Library | Current Activities
10. Activities available at other Christchurch Suburban Libraries &
11. Other Potential Reserve Users.

‘Shirley Centre 10 Shirley Road’ Facebook Page post, regarding the proposed ‘Shirley Community Reserve Landscape Plan’:
https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1C3uvkhiQJ/
(See Comments/Links)
The Waipapa Papanui-Innes-Central Community Board’s vision is for the:
“Shirley Community Reserve to become:
– a destination of choice for the community,
– a safe space,
– a place that enhances well-being, and
– provides a place for social connection.”
1. How can the Reserve be developed to invite more residents to ‘come, stay & play’?
2. What areas can be included to create a ‘safe, inclusive, intergenerational space’?
3. How can the Reserve be used to ‘enhance the well-being’ for all ages & stages of life?
4. Where are the opportunities for ‘passive’ (to be) & ‘active’ (to do) Reserve users?


4. Shirley Community Reserve Development Plan (Feedback Summary)
7.16 Early feedback sessions were held between December 2025 and June 2026 with Pareawa Banks Avenue Primary School, Te Hiwa Shirley Primary School and Te Oraka Shirley Intermediate School.
– ‘Dudley Creek’ theme
– natural materials and colours
– inclusive play space for all ages
– retaining the perimeter fence
– places for adults to sit and gather

7.25 Avon Ōtakaro Network Inc and Food Resilience Network Inc were concerned the plan over-emphasised infrastructure and didn’t do enough to improve ecological and environmental outcomes.
Ōtautahi Skate Association requested changes to the skate area.

7.27 Four submitters thought the skate area needed amending, three did not like the greenspace reduction.

7.31 Support for the lawn area near the community facility.
The skills loop area including road safety learning opportunities.
Interest in native planting and labels identifying trees in the reserve.
Increased security in the reserve, including amending the play whare to make sure rough sleepers cannot use it.
More Māori imagery and design throughout the play space.


5. CCC Staff Report & ‘Final Landscape Plan’ (My Feedback)
Below is my feedback regarding the CCC Staff Report & ‘Final Landscape Plan’:

– 5.1. Location Map & Safety Issues
The Landscape Plan has been designed in isolation within the Reserve, without considering the safety issues on Shirley Road.
https://smartview.ccc.govt.nz/data/road-crashes

Before I started advocating for 10 Shirley Road in 2018, I was advocating for the safety issues outside Shirley Primary School, asking the Council/Community Board in 2017 to address these issues.
https://www.10shirleyroad.org.nz/traffic-issues-outside-shirley-primary-email/

In the ‘Location Map’ below, I’ve highlighted the ‘Road’ Zone (Red Dotted Line).
This area needs to remain as a clear buffer zone, due to the amount of visual noise in front of the Reserve on Shirley Road.

Shirley Community Reserve is located between Hills & Marshland Road, which are key urban arterial routes, high-volume urban road (15,000+ per day), with many non-locals going past this location each day.

The four activities (Pump Track, Skate Area, Mega Swing, Adventure Climber) will involve young children making sudden & unpredictable movements.

These activities enable young children to be seen at ground level, flying through the air, climbing/standing on top & jumping off the proposed built infrastructure.
As they use these activities, falling down & getting hurt will occur, adding visual noise/distractions for all road & footpath users.

Young children will be running between activities & across paths, at the front of the Reserve. Drivers will be distracted by the movement.
Passengers seeing these activities may draw the attention of driver, away from the obstacles on the road/cycle lane/footpath.

These four activities would be best suited in MacFarlane Park South (off Jebson Street) behind the Shirley Primary School, as a new family friendly destination space, away from a busy main road, yet still easily accessible off Hills/Shirley Road.

Shirley Community Reserve, 10 Shirley Road, Richmond
‘Location Map & Safety Issues’
with CCC Staff ‘Final Landscape Plan’ Insert

The ‘Red’ numbers from 1 – 5, are highlighted for these reasons:
– ‘Red’ 1. Hills/Shirley Road Intersection: known safety issues/crashes, raised ‘Speed Hump Platform’ stop/start movements to get over/down the platform, red light runners turning right from Hills Road onto Shirley Road.
– ‘Red’ 2. Traffic splits into four directions: turning into/exiting the Shirley Shopping Centre car park, going straight, turning right & give way turning left with pedestrian crossing.
Give Way from Hills Road, turning left onto Shirley Road (North of No. 2).
Entrance/Exit from Shirley Shopping Centre car park (South of No. 2).
– ‘Red’ 3. Slater Street/Shirley Road Intersection: Buses pulling in/out both sides of the road.
Pedestrians & other footpath users waiting/crossing the street.
Shirley Road users waiting to turn right onto Slater Street, to access the Reserve car park & go to the new Community Centre building.
Slater Street users turning left/right onto Shirley Road, with cycle lanes/bus stop.
Shirley Road users turning left into Slater Street, with cycle lanes/bus stop.
– ‘Red’ 4. Signalised Pedestrian Crossing: Red light runners, distracted by the existing visual noise (two sets of lights close together) & different ages/mobility levels/transport modes all in one space.
Short term street parking on both sides of the road.
Bottleneck on footpaths either side of Shirley Road at peak times, with entrance/exit to Shirley Primary School (North) & Shirley Community Reserve (South).
– ‘Red’ 5. Chancellor Street/Shirley Road Intersection: Shirley Primary School Staff car park entrance/exit (North of No. 5).
Pedestrians & other footpath users waiting/crossing the street.
Shirley Road users waiting to turn right onto Chancellor Street, with cycle lanes.
Chancellor Street users turning left/right onto Shirley Road, with cycle lanes.


– 5.2. Reserve Classification & History
The 10 Shirley Road site has been a ‘place of learning’ since 1915.
In 1980, this site became the Shirley Community Reserve, a ‘Local Purpose’ reserve (site for a community centre).
This differs from a ‘Recreation’ reserve, like the MacFarlane Park in Shirley.

“the classification reflects the primary purpose of the reserve, but that does not prevent other compatible activities occurring there.
It is also possible to classify part of a reserve for one purpose and the other part or parts of the same reserve for any other purpose, but that would require a survey to define the separate parts.”
https://www.10shirleyroad.org.nz/email-to-the-department-of-conservation-17th-sept-2025/

The CCC Staff ‘Final Landscape Plan’ is generic, it could be located in any suburb in Christchurch.
After the Canterbury Earthquakes, we lost our homes, schools, churches, community facilities, local landmarks…
Now with the changes to the Christchurch District Plan, our standalone family homes with big backyards & garages are being demolished, to be replaced with multiple townhouses on the same site, with a small outdoor space & many without garages.

“4.47 The project scope is focused on providing community recreation and activity-based amenities that complement the new Community Centre and support Shirley Community Reserve as a local destination.” (CCC Staff Report)

The ‘Shirley Centre’ plan focuses on reinstating the ‘Community Centre’ building as the ‘primary’ purpose of the Reserve & keeping most of the Reserve as an Open Green Space, for all the residents in our communities to enjoy.
With “porous surfacing to allow water to drain away” for the ‘Play’ & ‘Move’ Zones.
Not by adding more concrete/asphalt, as in the CCC Staff ‘Final Landscape Plan’.

We can continue to honor this site as a ‘place of learning’, by connecting indoor & outdoor spaces, through activating the Reserve with different learning opportunities.
With complementary activities to ‘enhance the well-being’ of Reserve users, by providing ‘active’ options for all ages & stages, through the:
– ‘Play’ Zone (Babies, Preschoolers, Primary Aged Children):
Fully Fenced, Inclusive, Accessible Play Space for Children &
– ‘Move’ Zone (Youth, Adults, Older Adults):
Inclusive, Accessible, Intergenerational Outdoor Fitness Space.

‘Tell Our Stories’
4.29 Staff also received a request to incorporate some of the building material from the former community centre either in the new built or in the wider park.
As this request could not be accommodated in the new community centre built, staff have allowed for the inclusion of a historic plaque within the plaza space.

Foundation Stone and Foundation Deposit from the original building:
https://www.10shirleyroad.org.nz/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/ShirleyCommunityCentreBuildingRetrievals.pdf

Last year after much research, I was finally able to find more information & photos of the original building.
Including the original blueprints & hand drawn watercoloured plans by George Penlington, from 1915.

Where are the details that ‘Tell Our Stories’ of our communities identity & local history?
– History of the Land
– Original Shirley Road
– Original Shirley School
– George Penlington
– George Brington Malcolm
– Social Housing History
– Chancellor Street Heritage Houses
– Dudley Creek
– Dudley Character Area
– Shirley Community Centre
– Canterbury Earthquakes
– Dudley Creek Flood Remediation
– Shirley Community Centre Rebuild


– 5.3. Access, Visibility & Wayfinding
4.33 Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design (CPTED) principles have been considered in determining the overall layout and arrangement of the various activities, with a focus on increasing passive surveillance through proximity to the road and the new Community Centre.

4.36 The Final Landscape Plan for Shirley Community Reserves maintains some of the existing paths but also forms new path connections to provide greater access throughout the reserve.

The ‘blue highlight’ paths connect the new Community Centre building, does this plan consider the Shirley Playcentre users needs, for better access through the Reserve to the entrance/exit at Shirley Road?

Shirley Community Reserve Development Plan
Consultation Feedback by Joanna Gould
https://www.10shirleyroad.org.nz/reserve-development-plan-feedback/
‘Shirley Centre’ Plan
E.5. ‘Play’ Zone:
Fully Fenced, Inclusive, Accessible Play Space for Children
For more details see:
https://www.10shirleyroad.org.nz/reserve-development-plan-play-zone/
E.6. ‘Move’ Zone:
Inclusive, Accessible, Intergenerational Outdoor Fitness Space
For more details see:
https://www.10shirleyroad.org.nz/reserve-development-plan-move-zone/
E.7. ‘Grass’ Zone:
Large Open Space for outdoor activities to complement indoor activities
& opportunities to connect each Zone to the new building eg:
E.6.+E.7.+E.3. = ‘Move’ Zone combo or
E.5.+E.7.+E.3. = ‘Play’ Zone combo.
For more details see: Page 4 of my Consultation Feedback .pdf

The Shirley Road entrance gate/footpath into the Reserve is a bottleneck at drop off/pickup times.
Pedestrians crossing from Shirley Road trying to get into the Reserve, have to push past those waiting on the Reserve side to cross at the signalized pedestrian crossing.
Reducing the path width at this location is going to cause more problems & stress during peak times.
Proposing a Pump Track on one side of the main path, with a Skate Area on the other side, will require all Reserve users to get past this obstacle course.
It will be off putting for many potential users of the new Community Centre building.

My ‘Shirley Centre’ plan above, shows a wider path that splits into two paths to allow Reserve users different options, to make it easier to get where they need to go.
West Path: ‘Move’ Zone, Car Park, Community Centre building & access to Dudley Creek.
East Path: ‘Play’ Zone, Shirley Playcentre users, Community Centre building & access to Dudley Creek.
Footpaths: Wider than normal, easy to navigate, simple direct access from A to B.
Timber Boardwalks: Accessibility & safety issues due to slick surfaces for wheelchairs, mobility scooters & strollers.

‘F.5. Information Signs & Interpretation Board’
(White Triangle at Shirley Road Entrance)
– Information Sign 1:
‘You Are Here’, Location Map, Reserve Building Info, Booking Info, What’s On Info.
– Information Sign 2:
‘Need Help?’, Links to local Support Services (as requested by ReVision Youth Audit).
– Interpretation Board:
‘Tell Our Stories’, History of Shirley Road, Original Building, Local History etc.
This was requested by the Board in 2022, as suggested by the ‘Shirley Road Central’ residents group, that I was a part of.
“4.24 After discussion with representatives from the Shirley Road Central group it was agreed the Visitor Experience Team would also investigate developing one or two interpretation boards.
These would tell the stories of both local and city-wide significance; original school heritage buildings, community centre and its role in the community, historic domestic buildings adjacent to the park, and Dudley Creek remediation.
The Shirley Road Central group has provided reference material.”
https://www.10shirleyroad.org.nz/shirley-community-reserve-memo/

‘F.6. StoryWalk’
StoryWalk is an interactive outdoor literacy activity, where the pages of a children’s picture book are displayed on posts along a walking path, allowing families to read a story while walking through nature.
‘The Wonderful Stranges’ by Melanie Koster (Christchurch Author):
https://christchurch.bibliocommons.com/v2/record/S37C1567292

‘F.7. Footpath Games & Exercises’
Turn ordinary footpaths into active/engaging/movement paths, good for all ages & abilities. Also useful to redirect young children who need distracting when transitioning from the E.5. ‘Play’ Zone to leave the Reserve & go home, plus moving from the car park to go to the playcentre or school.


– 5.4. Activities & Funding
Q.1. Who will use the Reserve Outdoor Spaces the most?
People who are not in school or at work, during the day.
Preschoolers, Youth, Adults, Older Adults.

Q.2. What age group does the CCC Staff ‘Final Landscape Plan’ cater for through activities?
Primary/Intermediate school aged children, who already have access to their own school playgrounds.
The current playground caters to preschoolers, better than the proposed play space.
While Youth/Adults/Older Adults can either sit on a seat or the grass?

Q.3. How many different activities are included in the CCC Staff ‘Final Landscape Plan’?
Seven activities.
Basketball Court, Pump Track, Skate Area, Mega Swing, Adventure Climber, Accessible Play Space & Skills Loop.
In my ‘Shirley Centre’ plan there are two activity areas: ‘Play’ & ‘Move’ Zones.

Q.4. Given the limited budget, is it ‘value for money’ for the Board to invest in a few activities or more?
The proposed Basketball Court covers a large part of the Reserve.
Is it a waste of resources if only one person is shooting hoops, when there are already these ‘Recreation’ facilities available, at Avon Hub (other end of Shirley Road) & MacFarlane Park?
https://www.10shirleyroad.org.nz/shirley-centre-community-overview-map/
The ‘Pump Track, Skate Area, Mega Swing, Skills Loop’ activities have a limited number of participants, who can safely use these activities at the same time.
While the ‘Play’ & ‘Move’ Zones in my ‘Shirley Centre’ plan, allow many participants to engage in these spaces at the same time, creating more opportunities for social connections.
https://www.10shirleyroad.org.nz/local-green-spaces/

Q.5. If residents want a ‘Pump Track, Skate Area, Mega Swing, Adventure Climber, Skills Loop & the Table Tennis Table’ in MacFarlane Park South, how can the Board fund this?
By securing funding for the development of the new ‘MacFarlane Park South Play Space’ & ‘MacFarlane Park Community Garden Extension’, in the Long Term Plan next year.
Other funding partners:
Department of Internal Affairs, Kāinga Ora & Rātā Foundation?

New ‘MacFarlane Park South Play Space’
https://www.10shirleyroad.org.nz/macfarlane-park-south-play-space/
A | ‘Skills Loop’ Area, B | ‘Flying Fox’, C | ‘Pump Track’, D | ‘Skate Area’ &
E | ‘MacFarlane Park Community Garden Proposed Extension’
More space available to include the:
‘Mega Swing, Adventure Climber & Table Tennis Table’.

– 5.5. Reserve & Play Space Fencing
4.41 The area, identified by the orange line in Figure 6 [below] is the existing fencing. The proposed additional fencing is highlighted by the green lines. The Community Centre building (shown in blue) will form part of the enclosure; however, a small opening will remain between the basketball court and the south-western corner of the building, highlighted by red line.

Is there going to be a gate in the proposed ‘green highlight’ fence, from Shirley Playcentre to the new Community Centre building?

Feasibility Study 2023: “Opportunity to provide for inclusive play…Reserve is already currently fenced, which is rare particularly in the area north of Bealey Avenue…fenced playground…something the Disability community is advocating for more of, in particular the Autism community in Christchurch.”

A fully fenced play space is needed plus the perimeter fencing, to add two barriers between the busy Shirley Road & protect young children from dogs on the Reserve.

This will create a safe space for the Autism community in Christchurch & for families/parents/caregivers supervising more than one child playing at the Reserve.

Equity: Equality means each individual or group of people is given the same resources or opportunities.
Equity recognises that each person has different circumstances and allocates the exact resources and opportunities needed to reach an equal outcome.
People should have equity, regardless of age, gender, disability, ethnicity, culture, faiths, geographical location, sexual orientation, neurodiversity or socio-economic status.
https://www.10shirleyroad.org.nz/ccc-equity-and-inclusion-policy/

Reserve Development Plan

‘Shirley Community Reserve Development Plan’
Let’s Talk Consultation: 25 August – 13 September 2026
https://letstalk.ccc.govt.nz/SCRdevelopmentplan

Consultation Document:
Shirley Community Reserve Development Plan – Draft Plan
https://letstalk.ccc.govt.nz/download_file/9954/3472

Shirley Community Reserve Development Plan – Draft Plan | Overview

Overview | We’re proposing to improve Shirley Community Reserve so that locals have a space to play, connect and relax.
The Shirley Community Reserve development plan will focus on the green space north of the community facility and Shirley Playcentre.
The plan will enhance the activities at the community facility and provide a hub for Shirley residents.

Shirley Community Reserve Development Plan – Draft Plan | Activity Areas

Activity Areas | The Shirley Community Reserve development plan features seven separate areas:
– Mini basketball court
– Pump track
– Skate area
– Adventure play area
– Accessible play area
– Wheel skills loop area
– Lawn and plaza
The south side of the basketball court will be fenced to prevent basketballs from bouncing into the car park next door.
These areas have been chosen so that local residents and families and visitors can relax, play and socialise.
The areas also enhance the types of play in Shirley, complementing play spaces in St Albans Park, MacFarlane Park and in local schools.

Shirley Community Reserve Development Plan – Draft Plan | Play Spaces

Play Spaces | We worked with local students to determine what kind of equipment we should install.
The adventure play area will focus on challenging play, featuring an adventure climbing structure with handholds, slides and tunnels for imaginative play.
The adventure and spinner area will have bark soft fall.
The accessible play area will include equipment that can be enjoyed by people of all abilities. It will include rubber soft fall to provide accessibility for wheelchair and low mobility users.
A wavy wooden fence will separate the accessible play area from the lawn.

Shirley Community Reserve Development Plan – Draft Plan | Skate Area/Pump Track/Plaza

Skate Area/Pump Track/Plaza | The skate area, pump track and wheel skills loop track are designed to provide opportunities for young people to practice skills such as skateboarding, BMX biking and scootering.
The skate features have been chosen to complement the pump track and provide a clear path to ride between the pump track and the skate area.
The wheel skills loop track is designed for young children who are developing their riding skills and provide a safe, separate alternative to the pump track.
It will include wavy raised wooden paths, pillars to weave between and boardwalk detours. Lines will be painted on the tracks so users can choose between various difficulty levels.
The plaza will be a welcoming gathering area for families, caregivers and visitors, featuring a shelter offering shade and a place to rest and share kai.
Three picnic tables will be located within the plaza and a wooden boardwalk will connect to the accessible play area.
The existing table-tennis table will be relocated next to the plaza.

Inequitable Equity

“‘Inequitable Equity’ occurs when policies or systems designed to level the playing field inadvertently reinforce unfairness.
It happens when ‘fairness’ is applied uniformly without adjusting for pre-existing disadvantages, or when targeted resource distribution creates unintended secondary gaps.” AI Overview

“‘Inequitable means unfair, unjust, or failing to treat everyone equally.
It describes situations, decisions, or systems characterized by a lack of balance, impartiality, or justice, that fail to provide a just distribution of resources and opportunities.” AI Overview

‘Equity’ Definition from the Christchurch City Council Equity & Inclusion Policy:
https://ccc.govt.nz/the-council/plans-strategies-policies-and-bylaws/policies/strengthening-communities-policies/equity-and-inclusion-policy
“Equality means each individual or group of people is given the same resources or opportunities.
Equity recognises that each person has different circumstances and allocates the exact resources and opportunities needed to reach an equal outcome.
People should have equity, regardless of age, gender, disability, ethnicity, culture, faiths, geographical location, sexual orientation, neurodiversity or socio-economic status.”


“‘Council Core Services’ refer to the essential, primary functions local authorities prioritize and fund through local rates.
In New Zealand, Local Councils provide essential infrastructure, public services, and regulatory functions.
Under the Local Government Act, Councils are legally required to prioritize the cost-effective provision of these fundamental services to their communities:
– Network Infrastructure: Roading, transport networks, and water infrastructure (drinking water, wastewater, and stormwater).
– Public Transport Services: Management and facilitation of local public transit.
– Waste Management: Solid waste collection, recycling, and disposal.
– Civil Defence Emergency Management: Hazard mitigation, emergency preparedness, and disaster response coordination.
– Community Facilities: Libraries, museums, parks, reserves, and recreational amenities.” AI Overview

Local Government (System Improvements) Amendment Bill: A new focus on Core Functions
https://www.al.nz/local-government-system-improvements-amendment-bill-a-new-focus-on-core-functions/
“A pivotal aspect of the Bill is the proposed amendment to the statutory purpose of local government in the Local Government Act 2002 (LGA).
Critically, it aims to remove all references to the “four well-beings” – social, economic, environmental, and cultural – which themselves were reinstated in the legislation in 2019.
The Government’s policy is that these broader well-beings have contributed to councils undertaking activities perceived as beyond their fundamental remit, thereby adding to rates.
In their place, the Bill proposes a purpose statement focused explicitly on the cost-effective provision of good-quality local infrastructure and public services.
Councils will be legally obliged to consider these core services when fulfilling their responsibilities and formulating their financial management strategies.
This is designed to ensure that resources are predominantly allocated to essential services that directly benefit the local community.”


“Inequitable Council Funding refers to the disproportionate distribution of local government resources, where certain wards, demographic groups, or community initiatives receive less financial support than others.
This often results in unequal access to essential infrastructure, recreational facilities, and social services across a region.
In Christchurch, funding distribution has become a central point of debate, with ongoing tensions regarding the allocation of ratepayer funds.
Inequitable Council Funding often emerges when Councils rely heavily on property rates to fund community services.
This model disproportionately benefits wealthier property owners and central commercial hubs, leaving disadvantaged or fast-growing suburban and regional areas underfunded.
Older, well-established areas often require expensive maintenance of existing infrastructure, whereas newly expanding suburbs demand new amenities, creating tension over where limited ratepayer funds are distributed.” AI Overview


“The Canterbury Earthquakes of 2010 and 2011 caused severe land damage and liquefaction across Christchurch’s north-eastern and eastern flat land suburbs, resulting in the demolition of thousands of residential properties, commercial hubs, and beloved community heritage sites.
The most notable landmarks and institutional buildings lost in these suburbs around Shirley Road include:
– Local Schools: Major disruptions led to the structural condemnation, closures, or eventual relocations of several educational facilities in the broader catchment area, including Shirley Boys’ High School, Marian College, and Banks Avenue School.
– Shirley Community Centre (10 Shirley Road): A centerpiece of the neighborhood originally built in 1915 as Shirley School. The historic Category 2 building was heavily compromised by the shaking and demolished in 2012.” AI Overview

Since 2012, residents have been asking Council to reinstate their Community Centre at 10 Shirley Road.
https://www.10shirleyroad.org.nz/shirley-community-centre-decision-making/

‘Christchurch suburb overlooked since the earthquakes, community leaders say’ (30th April 2018)
https://www.stuff.co.nz/the-press/news/103484014/christchurch-suburb-overlooked-since-the-earthquakes-community-leaders-say
“Our ward has been forgotten in many ways, particularly the Shirley area – an area that is in the east but not in the east we hear so much about. No big pool complex or hot pools here,” [Former] Papanui Innes Community Board chairwoman Ali Jones said referring to facilities being built in neighbouring wards.
“The community is close to breaking point. They need a place to meet, to gather, to mend.”
When asked by a councillor how the council would pay for more facilities in the area, Jones said maybe other wards could cut back on some of the facilities they were asking for.
[Former] Christchurch Mayor Lianne Dalziel said reinstating a community centre in Shirley would have to be weighed up against all the other challenges facing the city.
“You do need to take a city view when you sit around this table. You can’t take a ward by ward view. We have to work out ways of making sure we have enough money on budget to do what is absolutely core critical across the city.”
Coastal-Burwood Community Board members also made a plea to the council for greater investment in the area to give it equity with the rest of the city.
The Shirley Community Centre, once a busy focal point providing a home to many different groups, was demolished following the 2010/11 earthquakes and has yet to be rebuilt. No money has been allocated in the LTP to build a replacement facility.
Shirley resident Joanna Gould said the community had become displaced since the demolition of the community centre.
“There is no one place to go to ask for help.”
Gould has created a website to push for a new joint library, learning centre, service centre, playground and playcentre at the site.”

Since 2018, I have been researching & advocating for my ‘Shirley Centre’ vision, to benefit the residents living in the communities around Shirley Road:
Shirley, Dallington, Richmond, Edgeware, St Albans & Mairehau.
https://www.10shirleyroad.org.nz/joanna-gould-submissions/


During this year’s Christchurch City Council 2026 Draft Annual Plan hearings, I appealed to Council & Councillors to ‘Cancel the Plan’ & reallocate the funding on budget into the 2027 LTP for the ‘Shirley Centre’.

Following my verbal submission, I created the below Blog Post series:
– Blog Post #1: CCC Draft Annual Plan 2026-2027
– Blog Post #2: Facility Decision-making
– Blog Post #3: Equity and Inclusion
– Blog Post #4: ‘Gateway to the East’
– Blog Post #5: ‘Cancel’ Plan or ‘Rip Up’ Policy?


In May 2026, I wrote the following Blog Post: ‘The Big Picture’:
“‘The Big Picture’ planning & development of the 10 Shirley Road site: Shirley Community Reserve, should focus on these 3 questions & 2 answers:
1. Q.1. Land?
– What can & can not be done with the Land?
2. Q.2. Council?
– What are the relevant Council plans, policies & strategies?
3. Q.3. Community?
– What does the Community want & need?
4. A.1. = Options
– What are the different scenarios currently available?
5. A.2. = Funding
– What are the different funding options available?”

I had hoped that after reading all my research over the years & understanding our communities needs, Councillors wouldn’t think ‘not my people, not my problem’…
But would act on our communities behalf, to ‘Cancel the Plan’ during their Workshops to finalise the Christchurch City Council Annual Plan for 2026 & rethink the plans for 10 Shirley Road.


Unfortunately this week I was notified by a Chancellor Street resident that a Christchurch City Council ‘Works Notice’ had been delivered to their letterbox:
‘Shirley Community Reserve – facility construction’
https://ccc.govt.nz/transport/works-3/show/2056
– What: Christchurch City Council is building a community facility [no longer called the ‘Shirley Community Centre’] at Shirley Community Reserve.
– Why: To deliver a community facility available for hire by local groups, along with public restrooms and an improved car park for park visitors.
[Existing car park reduced from 29 spaces to 16 spaces: 14 with 2 Mobility Car Parks.
This will have a negative impact on Shirley Playcentre & Shirley Primary School car park users.]
– Where: 10 Shirley Road, Shirley [Richmond].
– When: Early July 2026 to late December 2026. Monday to Friday, 7am to 6pm (weather/site condition dependent).

I am beyond disappointed. This is not the outcome I had hoped for our communities most valuable (history, heritage, reserve, accessible) site/land.

Residents in our communities surrounding Shirley Road, have been waiting patiently for their turn, to have their well used Community Centre rebuilt…
Paying their rates while watching other communities in Christchurch get their new (not all earthquake rebuilds) community facilities built & opened for their residents to enjoy.

The ‘Shirley Community Centre’ (1,500m2, Category 2 historic place) is the last remaining community facility, that was part of the Christchurch City Council’s original ‘Community Facilities Rebuild Programme’ to be rebuilt after the earthquakes.


‘Shirley Community Facility’ Written Submission by Joanna Gould (Sept 2025)
.pdf: https://www.10shirleyroad.org.nz/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/WaipapaPICItem8ShirleyCommunityFacilitySept2025JoannaGould.pdf

‘Shirley Community Facility’ Written Submission by Joanna Gould (Dec 2025)
.pdf: https://www.10shirleyroad.org.nz/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/WaipapaPICItem9ShirleyCommunityFacilityDec2025JoannaGould.pdf

At their 11th December 2025 meeting, the Waipapa Papanui-Innes-Central Community Board approved plans for the ‘Shirley Community Facility’.
https://www.10shirleyroad.org.nz/shirley-community-facility-plan-v2/

The new Shirley Community Reserve ‘Community Facility’:
– 280m2 building
– For Hire only: function room, a kitchen, office space, two meeting rooms & four internal toilets.
– Free Access: two external public toilets.


So after researching, advocating, filling in surveys/consultations, making deputations/submissions, ‘activation’ of the site, organising/presenting a petition & waiting since 2012 for a new building to ‘replace’ our former Centre…

The Waipapa Papanui Innes Central Community Board & Christchurch City Council have come to the conclusion, that what our communities really need at the most visible & accessible location on Shirley Road, is free access to two external public toilets?

Where is the equity?
https://www.10shirleyroad.org.nz/equity-and-inclusion/
How does this new ‘Community Facility’ include residents in our communities, who are socially isolated due to financial constraints?

Our current residents & future generations living in these communities around Shirley Road, have been let down by:
– our Innes (Pauline Cotter) & Central (Jake McLellan) Ward Councillors (10 Shirley Road site was originally in the Innes Ward, now in the Central Ward),
– the Waipapa Papanui Innes Central Community Board for approving this plan &
– our current Christchurch City Councillors who could have chosen to ‘Cancel the Plan’ & advocate for a new design to be created, for a fit-for-purpose building that aligns with the ‘Equity and Inclusion Policy’, to meet our communities needs.

Christchurch City Council, please rip up your ‘Equity and Inclusion Policy’, as this new ‘Community Facility’ at 10 Shirley Road does not align with your policy definitions.

Shirley Community Facility Plan v2

1. Waipapa Papanui-Innes-Central Community Board
Meeting Agenda for 11th December 2025
2. Waipapa Papanui-Innes-Central Community Board
Meeting Minutes for 11th December 2025
3. Waipapa Papanui-Innes-Central Community Board
Meeting Minutes Attachments for 11th September 2025
(No Attachments were included, even though the Board received emails).
4. Waipapa Papanui-Innes-Central Community Board
YouTube Video of the 11th December 2025 Board Meeting
(No Deputations were allowed for this Item).
5. ‘Shirley Community Facility’ Written Submission by Joanna Gould
(including AI Summary of .pdf)


1. Waipapa Papanui-Innes-Central Community Board
Meeting Agenda for 11th December 2025

https://christchurch.infocouncil.biz/Open/2025/12/PCBCC_20251211_AGN_10741_AT.PDF
9. Updated Shirley Community Facility Design
– Pages 13-24: Council Staff Report
– Pages 25-31: Co-Studio Architects Developed Design for the Shirley Community Facility v2
– Pages 32-38: Co-Studio Architects Developed Design for the Shirley Community Facility v1.


2. Waipapa Papanui-Innes-Central Community Board
Meeting Minutes for 11th December 2025

https://christchurch.infocouncil.biz/Open/2025/12/PCBCC_20251211_MIN_10741_AT.PDF
Pages 4-6
9. Updated Shirley Community Facility Design
– Community Board Consideration
The Board accepted the Officer Recommendations, except in respect of it selecting the option of having a raked ceiling for the facility, rather than a flat ceiling.
The Board also added resolution 7 below to enable the two meeting rooms in the updated facility design to be accessed independently of the function space via external doors that it requested the identified windows be replaced with.
The Board’s consideration confirmed that the authority given to staff to amend the updated design included determining whether the added doors be single or double.
Victoria Henstock foreshadowed moving the Officer Recommendations without change, but the addition of a raked ceiling, and external doors for the meeting rooms, was carried before the foreshadowed motion could be put to a vote.
– Officer Recommendations Ngā Tūtohu
That the Waipapa Papanui-Innes-Central Community Board:
1. Receives the information in the Updated Shirley Community Facility Design Report.
2. Notes that the decision in this report is assessed as low significance based on the Christchurch City Council’s Significance and Engagement Policy.
3. Approves the updated developed detail design, including a flat ceiling and associated project costings, incorporating the Board’s September 2025 directions, as shown in Attachment A to this report.
4. Instructs staff to proceed to tender and procurement following approval of the updated design and project costings.
5. Acknowledges the mahi of the Shirley Working Group and thanks them for their contribution to the project.
6. Notes that the total project remains deliverable within the Long-Term Plan budget of $3,705,000.
– Community Board Resolved PCBCC/2025/00074
Part C
That the Waipapa Papanui-Innes-Central Community Board:
1. Receives the information in the Updated Shirley Community Facility Design Report.
2. Notes that the decision in this report is assessed as low significance based on the Christchurch City Council’s Significance and Engagement Policy.
3. Subject to resolution 7, approves the updated developed detail design, including a raked ceiling and associated project costings, incorporating the Board’s September 2025 directions, as shown in Attachment A to the report.
4. Instructs staff to proceed to tender and procurement following approval of the updated design and project costings.
5. Acknowledges the mahi of the Shirley Working Group and thanks them for their contribution to the project.
6. Notes that the total project remains deliverable within the Long-Term Plan budget of $3,705,000.
7. Requests and authorises staff to amend the updated design by replacing:
a. the external window in Meeting Room 04; and
b. the south-western external window in Large Meeting Room 03;
with external glass doors of the same style as the other external doors in the facility, to enable those rooms to be accessed independently of the function space.
– Pauline Cotter/Jake McLellan Carried
9. Updated Shirley Community Facility Design Voting:
– For (6): Pauline Cotter, Jake McLellan, Dr Sunita Gautam, John Miller, Mike Davidson, Simon Britten
– Against (1): Emma Twaddell
– Abstain (2): Ashleigh Feary, Victoria Henstock
TOTAL = 9


3. Waipapa Papanui-Innes-Central Community Board
Meeting Minutes Attachments for 11th September 2025

(No Attachments were included, even though the Board received emails).


4. Waipapa Papanui-Innes-Central Community Board
YouTube Video of the 11th December 2025 Board Meeting
(No Deputations were allowed for this Item).
Presentation & Board Discussions for Item 9. Updated Shirley Community Facility Design:
https://www.youtube.com/live/RRceb032Avw?t=5691s


5. ‘Shirley Community Facility’ Written Submission by Joanna Gould
.pdf: https://www.10shirleyroad.org.nz/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/WaipapaPICItem9ShirleyCommunityFacilityDec2025JoannaGould.pdf
Includes information on the following topics:
– Shirley Community Facility | Developed Design | December 2025
– Proposed Shirley Community Facility | Feedback from September 2025
– Dudley Character Area, Richmond | Dudley Design Guide
– 10 Shirley Road & Original Building | Connections
– St Albans Community Centre | Concept Plan & Consultation
– Lancaster Park Community Centre and Changing Rooms
– Department of Conservation Email | Reserve Classification & Uses
– Shirley Community Reserve | Redevelopment Concept for Discussion
– CCC Community Facilities Network Plan | Principles
– CCC Community Facilities Network Plan | Best Practice Community Facility Design
– Christchurch City Council District Plan | Housing Intensification & Property Values
– Kāinga Ora | New Social Housing Developments
– Bookable Spaces & Local Activities Provided
– Shirley Centre | Ideas by Joanna Gould (2021)

AI Summary of .pdf:
“The document outlines concerns, feedback, and suggestions regarding the proposed Shirley Community Facility redevelopment at Shirley Community Reserve, as well as comparisons to other community projects and guidelines. Below are the key points:

Concerns with the Proposed Shirley Community Facility Design (December 2025)
– Building Placement:
Located at the back of the reserve, hidden from Shirley Road, and not aligned with the existing path. ​
South wall blocks the line of sight from Shirley Road to Dudley Creek, raising CPTED (Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design) concerns. ​
– Design Issues:
Meeting rooms are fixed spaces, not adjustable. ​
Access to meeting rooms is through the function space, which may limit usability. ​
The projector wall removes windows on the east side, blocking visibility to the playground and Shirley Playcentre. ​
The building lacks windows or doors on the south side, missing the best view of Dudley Creek. ​
Roof pitch, entrance location, and window styles do not align with the Dudley Design Guide for the area.
– Interior Design:
The new building is a single-room facility, unlike the former multi-room community center. ​
No clarity on whether items from the former heritage-listed building will be incorporated.
– Car Park and Paths:
Reduced car park spaces may impact Shirley Primary School and Shirley Playcentre. ​
The new car park is disconnected from existing paths, affecting accessibility. ​
The building is not connected to Shirley Road, the playground, or Shirley Playcentre.
– Toilets and Kitchen:
Lack of windows in toilets and kitchen increases electricity and ventilation costs. ​
Concerns about vandalism and maintenance of public toilets. ​

– Feedback and Advocacy:
The facility was designed without sufficient resident input and is deemed not “fit for purpose.” ​
Residents prefer a community-focused facility rather than a venue for hire or clubroom. ​
The facility should honor the area’s history and provide inclusive spaces for current and future residents. ​

– Reserve Classification and Legal Implications:
The land is classified as a “Local Purpose Reserve” for a community center, which limits its use to this purpose unless the classification is changed. ​
Mixed-use activities are permissible if compatible with the reserve’s primary purpose. ​

– Comparisons to Other Community Projects:
The St Albans Community Centre involved extensive public consultation and a community-led design process, which was not followed for the Shirley Community Facility.
Lancaster Park Community Centre has a larger building size and more amenities compared to the proposed Shirley Community Facility. ​

– Recommendations:
Align the design with the CCC Community Facilities Network Plan principles, emphasizing community-led design, inclusivity, flexibility, and integration with surroundings. ​
Incorporate local history and retrieved items from the former heritage-listed building. ​
Improve accessibility and connectivity to surrounding paths, playgrounds, and public transport. ​
Address concerns about the building’s placement, design, and usability. ​

– Additional Context:
The Shirley Community Reserve has been underutilized since the original community center was demolished in 2012 due to earthquake damage. ​
The area is experiencing housing intensification, with new social housing developments expected to bring approximately 198 new residents by May 2026. ​
The document includes links to resources, community groups, and design guidelines for further reference. ​

– Conclusion:
The document emphasizes the need for a community-led, inclusive, and functional design for the Shirley Community Facility that aligns with the reserve’s purpose and addresses residents’ needs.
It highlights the importance of integrating the facility with its surroundings and honoring the area’s history while accommodating future growth.”

Shirley Community Facility Plan v1

1. Waipapa Papanui-Innes-Central Community Board
Meeting Agenda for 11th September 2025
2. Waipapa Papanui-Innes-Central Community Board
Meeting Minutes for 11th September 2025
3. Waipapa Papanui-Innes-Central Community Board
Meeting Minutes Attachments for 11th September 2025
4. Waipapa Papanui-Innes-Central Community Board
YouTube Video of the 11th September 2025 Board Meeting
(including Deputations by: Jennifer Dalziel, Margaret Stewart, Joanna Gould, Don Gould, Jo Byrne, Murray James from We Are Richmond & Jane Mitchell from Shirley Community Trust).
5. ‘Shirley Community Facility’ Written Submission by Joanna Gould
(including AI Summary of .pdf)


1. Waipapa Papanui-Innes-Central Community Board
Meeting Agenda for 11th September 2025
:
https://christchurch.infocouncil.biz/Open/2025/09/PCBCC_20250911_AGN_9141_AT.PDF
Item 8. Shirley Community Facility
– Pages 26 – 35: Council Staff Report
– Pages 36 – 62: Co-Studio Architects Developed Design for the Shirley Community Facility.


2. Waipapa Papanui-Innes-Central Community Board
Meeting Minutes for 11th September 2025
:
https://christchurch.infocouncil.biz/Open/2025/09/PCBCC_20250911_MIN_9141_AT.PDF
Item 8. Shirley Community Facility
– Board Consideration
The Board considered the deputations on this item (refer 5.3 – 5.8 of these minutes) before accepting the Officer Recommendations with a variation on Option Two, increasing the footprint by at least 100 square metres to make the centre large enough to contain three separate or separatable meeting/activity rooms.
The Board also added requests that staff investigate including in the final design the building elements listed in resolution 6, and noted that the rotunda (or another form of shelter) will be investigated by Parks staff as part of their redevelopment proposal for the reserve.
– Officer Recommendations Ngā Tūtohu
That the Waipapa Papanui-Innes-Central Community Board:
1. Receives the information in the Shirley Community Facility Report.
2. Notes that the decision in this report is assessed as low significance based on the
Christchurch City Council’s Significance and Engagement Policy.
3. Acknowledges the mahi of the Shirley Working Group and thanks them for their contribution to the project.
4. Notes the Shirley Working Group’s endorsement of the developed design for the Shirley Community Facility.
5. Approves:
a. option one, the developed design as endorsed by the Shirley Working
Group as shown in Attachment A, for inclusion in the detailed design phase and associated comprehensive project cost report.
Or;
b. option two, the developed design and extension to the building, as shown in Attachment B for inclusion in the detailed design phase and associated comprehensive project cost report.
6. Requests staff incorporate the proposed rotunda, as shown in Attachment C, for inclusion in the detailed design phase and associated comprehensive project cost report.
7. Requests staff to report back to the Board with the detailed design and comprehensive project cost report for approval.
8. Requests staff collaborate with the Parks Unit to ensure this project is integrated with the development of a landscape plan for Shirley Reserve, and to explore opportunities for delivery efficiencies.
– Community Board Resolved PCBCC/2025/00057
Part C
That the Waipapa Papanui-Innes-Central Community Board:
1. Receives the information in the Shirley Community Facility Report.
2. Notes that the decision in this report is assessed as low significance based on the Christchurch City Council’s Significance and Engagement Policy.
3. Acknowledges the mahi of the Shirley Working Group and thanks them for their contribution to the project.
4. Notes the Shirley Working Group’s endorsement of the developed design (as outlined in Option One and in Attachment A to this report) for the Shirley Community Facility.
5. Approves the developed design with an increase to the footprint by at least 100 square metres to make the centre large enough to contain three separate or separatable meeting/activity rooms, while remaining within budget, for inclusion in the detailed design phase and associated comprehensive project cost report.
6. Requests that staff investigate:
a. constructing the building with an internal exposed raked ceiling;
b. including solar panels and a battery;
c. including an office space;
d. including and fitting a large screen.
7. Notes that Parks staff will include investigating a shelter/rotunda as part of their redevelopment proposal.
8. Requests staff to report back to the Board with the detailed design and associated project costings for approval.
9. Requests staff collaborate with the Parks Unit to ensure this project is integrated with the development of a landscape plan for Shirley Reserve, and to explore opportunities for delivery efficiencies.
– Pauline Cotter/Sunita Gautam Carried
– Emma Norrish requested that her vote against the resolutions be recorded.


3. Waipapa Papanui-Innes-Central Community Board
Meeting Minutes Attachments for 11th September 2025
:
https://christchurch.infocouncil.biz/Open/2025/09/PCBCC_20250911_MAT_9141.PDF
– Pages 16-26: 5.5. Deputation by Joanna Gould for the Shirley Community Facility
– Pages 27-30: 5.6. Deputation by Don Gould for the Shirley Community Facility


4. Waipapa Papanui-Innes-Central Community Board
Youtube Video of the 11th September 2025 Board Meeting

– Deputations for Item 8. Shirley Community Facility:
https://www.youtube.com/live/4cCkAA7KvZg?si=xU09YWM8HoBE6ww4&t=1395s
5.3 Jennifer Dalziel
Jennifer Dalziel spoke regarding Item 8, Shirley Community Facility.
5.4 Margaret Stewart
Margaret Stewart spoke regarding Item 8, Shirley Community Facility.
5.5 Joanna Gould
Joanna Gould spoke regarding Item 8, Shirley Community Facility.
5.6 Don Gould
Don Gould spoke regarding Item 8, Shirley Community Facility.
5.7 Jo Byrne
Jo Byrne spoke regarding Item 8, Shirley Community Facility.
5.8 We Are Richmond and Shirley Community Trust
Murray James and Jane Mitchell spoke on behalf of We Are Richmond and Shirley Community Trust respectively regarding Item 8, Shirley Community Facility.
– Presentation & Board Discussions for Item 8. Shirley Community Facility:
https://www.youtube.com/live/4cCkAA7KvZg?t=6367s


5. ‘Shirley Community Facility’ Written Submission by Joanna Gould
.pdf: https://www.10shirleyroad.org.nz/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/WaipapaPICItem8ShirleyCommunityFacilitySept2025JoannaGould.pdf
Includes information on the following topics:
Section A: Staff Report
Section B: Developed Design
1. Building Placement
2. Dudley Creek
3. Dudley Design
4. Interior
5. Car Park
6. Paths
7. Toilets & Kitchen
Section C: Additional Information
– Shirley Community Facility | Developed Design
– Dudley Design Guide
– Chancellor Street Heritage Houses (opposite Shirley Community Reserve)
– Heritage New Zealand Site Record & Photos of the former Shirley Community Centre building
– Shirley Community Centre – Landscape Development Proposals – May 1994
– Shirley Community Centre – 10 Shirley Road Retrievals – November 2012
– Shirley Community Centre | Ideas by Joanna Gould (2018)
– Shirley Centre | Design Considerations
– Shirley Centre | Design Inspiration
– Shirley Centre | Ideas by Joanna Gould (2021)

AI Summary of .pdf:
“The document outlines the agenda and concerns surrounding the proposed Shirley Community Facility to be constructed on Shirley Community Reserve at 10 Shirley Road. ​ Below are the key points:

Section A: Staff Report ​
– Purpose of the Report: Approval of the developed design for the Shirley Community Facility. ​
– Timing Concerns: The report is presented at the last meeting before elections, raising concerns about fairness to the incoming board and lack of transparency in decision-making. ​
– Community Advocacy: Residents have been advocating for a replacement building since the original Shirley Community Centre was demolished in 2012. ​ Progress has been slow despite its designation as a priority project. ​
– Working Group Issues:
The Shirley Working Group was established to advise on the design but lacked representation from key community stakeholders (e.g., Shirley Playcentre, Shirley Recreational Walkers, Shirley Primary School, and residents). ​
Endorsement of the design was divided, with some members opposing it. ​
– Budget Concerns:
The project budget is $3.7M, but the developed design is estimated at $1.6M, leaving $2.1M unallocated. ​
The new building is significantly smaller (236.9m²) than the original (1,500m²), raising concerns about its adequacy. ​
– Legal and Community Implications:
The land is classified as a “Local Purpose (Community Centre)” reserve, limiting its use. ​
High community interest in the project has not been adequately addressed, and residents feel excluded from the decision-making process. ​

Section B: Developed Design
– Building Placement:
The building is located at the back of the reserve, disconnected from Shirley Road and the existing paths. ​
Concerns about Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design (CPTED) issues due to the building’s placement and lack of visibility.
– Design Concerns:
The building design does not align with the Dudley Design Guide or the architectural style of surrounding residential buildings. ​
Lack of windows and doors facing Dudley Creek, which is a key feature of the reserve. ​
The interior design is limited to one room, reducing the facility’s functionality compared to the original multi-room building.
– Car Park and Pathway Issues:
Reduced car park spaces may impact Shirley Primary School and Shirley Playcentre. ​
The new building is not connected to existing paths or key areas like Shirley Road, the playground, or Shirley Playcentre.
– Toilets and Kitchen:
Lack of windows in the toilets and kitchen raises concerns about ventilation and energy costs. ​
The inclusion of public toilets is debated due to potential issues with vandalism and maintenance. ​

Section C: Additional Information
– Historical and Design Context:
The former Shirley Community Centre was a heritage-listed building with significant architectural and historical value. ​
The Dudley Design Guide emphasizes maintaining the character of the area, which the new design does not fully adhere to.
– Community Concerns:
Residents have expressed dissatisfaction with the lack of consultation and transparency. ​
There are questions about the allocation of the remaining budget and whether it will benefit other organizations that endorsed the plans.
– Key Issues Raised:
Lack of community involvement and transparency in the decision-making process. ​
Concerns about the adequacy of the new building’s size and design. ​
Questions about the allocation of the remaining budget. ​
Exclusion of key community stakeholders from the Working Group. ​
Disconnection of the new building from the reserve’s existing paths and features. ​

The document highlights significant community concerns about the proposed Shirley Community Facility, including its design, placement, budget allocation, and the decision-making process.”